Developing a Model for Measuring and Evaluating the Role of Commodities as Hedging Tools in Investor Portfolios

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Ph.D. Candidate., Department of Accounting, Faculty of Humanities, Kermanshah Branch, Islamic Azad University, Kermanshah, Iran.

2 Assistant Prof., Department of Accounting, Faculty of Humanities, Kermanshah Branch, Islamic Azad University, Kermanshah, Iran.

3 Assistant Prof., Department of Economic, Faculty of Humanities, Kermanshah Branch, Islamic Azad University, Kermanshah, Iran.

Abstract

Objective
This study investigated the role of commodities as independent investment tools, determined their interrelationships, explored their behavior within hybrid portfolios, and sought to identify suitable relationships for portfolio selection decisions between commodities and the stock index. The primary goal was to examine the diversification and hedging (safe haven) properties of assets and future commodities in Iran's exchange market compared to stocks during "bull and bear periods of the stock market" and to determine the minimum variance portfolio.
 
Methods
This research was applied in purpose and quantitative in methodology. The research approach was deductive (comparative), investigating expected empirical benefits using historical data. The study was theoretically categorized as proof research and, statistically, as a correlational study (econometric models). To this end, regression models of market tests, dynamic conditional correlation (DCC-GARCH), and the Markowitz model (portfolio optimization) were applied to daily data from the stock and commodity markets over 11 years from 2009 to 2020.
 
Results
The findings revealed that commodities, on their own, present a high-risk investment. Gold is the only commodity comparable to the stock market, which shares similar returns and volatility. Except for copper, other commodities have significantly higher volatility but lower efficiency than the stock index. Regarding the market test model, results indicated that some commodities had the appropriate hedging ability as a “safe haven” in different stock market regimes (business cycle phases). In portfolio construction, adding a single commodity to a quantitative stock portfolio resulted in low returns, offset by reduced fluctuations. However, the results showed that a “commodities portfolio” outperformed a “single portfolio”. When adding a commodities portfolio or a commodity index to the hybrid portfolio, the stock index still held the largest weight (around 94%), but the average portfolio risk was notably reduced (approximately 1/557), yielding an improved Sharpe ratio.
 
Conclusion
According to the findings, investing in commodities is a better option for reaping the benefits of diversification. Furthermore, when making investment decisions, the bull and bear periods of the stock market should be considered, as the findings revealed that business cycle phases are a strong indicator for the tactical allocation of commodities. The results of this study also support the evidence that the behavior of different commodity groups varies significantly. Finally, hedging is not always a safe haven for the stock market, and the reverse is also true.

Keywords

Main Subjects

References

 
Abanomey, W. S. & Mathur, I. )2000(. The hedging benefits of commodity futures in international portfolio diversification. The Journal of Alternative Investments, 2(3), 51-62.
Abdollahian, F. (2018). Designing and developing a mathematical model for predicting periods of boom and bust in Tehran Stock Exchange with emphasis on its effective indicators. PhD dissertation, Islamic Azad University, Centeral Tehran. (in Persian)
Adams, Z., Fuss, R. & Kaiser, D. )2008(. Macroeconomic determinants of commodity futures returns. The Handbook of Commodity Investing, 87-112.
Akpak Aygul, M. )2016(. An examination of commodity derivative markets: efficiency, volatility and diversification benefits. PhD dissertation, University of Essex.
Anson, M. J., Fabozzi, F. J. & Jones, F. J. )2010(. The handbook of traditional and alternative investment vehicles: investment characteristics and strategies (Vol. 194). John Wiley & Sons.
Baur, D. G. & Lucey, B. M. (2010). Is gold a hedge or a safe haven? An analysis of stocks, bonds and gold. Financial Review, 45(2), 217-229.
Baur, D. G. & McDermott, T. K. (2010). Is gold a safe haven? International evidence. Journal of Banking & Finance, 34(8), 1886-1898.
Bhardwaj, G., Gorton, G. & Rouwenhorst, G. (2015). Facts and fantasies about commodity futures ten years later (No. w21243). National Bureau of Economic Research.
Buyukşahin, B. & Robe, M. A. )2014(. Speculators, commodities and cross-market linkages. Journal of International Money and Finance, 42, 38-70.
Daigler, R. T., Dupoyet, B. & You, L. )2017(. Spicing up a Portfolio with Commodity Futures: Still a Good Recipe? The Journal of Alternative Investments, 19(4), 8-23.
Demidova-Menzel, N. & Heidorn, T. )2007(. Commodities in asset management. Working paper series. Frankfurt School of Finance & Management.
Engle, R. )2002(. Dynamic Conditional Correlation: A Simple Class of Multivariate Generalized Autoregressive Conditional Heteroskedasticity Models. Journal of Business and Economic Statistics, 20(3), 339-350.
Filiptchuk, K. & Lindholm, H. )2011(. Portfolio Optimization with Commodities - Sub-Sector and Business Cycle Analysis. Master Thesis in Finance.
Franch, M. & Shehabi, B. )2016(. A study of the properties related to the investment in several commodities and adding them to stock portfolios. Master thesis, Umea School of Business and Economics.
Gorton, G. & Rouwenhorst, K. G. )2006(. Facts and fantasies about commodity futures. Financial Analysts Journal, 62(2), 47-68.
Greer, R. J. )1978(. Conservative commodities: A key inflation hedge. The Journal of Portfolio Management, 4(4), 26-29.
Haneklaus, Li. B. & Rahman, M. M. (2024). Dynamic connectedness and hedging opportunities of the commodity and stock markets in China: evidence from the TVP-VAR and cDCC-FIAPARCH. Financial Innovation, 10(1), 52.‏
Hattingh, J. J. (2004). Portfolio management: the use of alternative investments for the purpose of diversification (Doctoral dissertation, University of Johannesburg).
Hood, M. & Malik, F. (2013). Is gold the best hedge and a safe haven under changing stock market volatility?. Review of Financial Economics, 22(2), 47-52.
Hossein Zadeh, H. (2018). Hedge and safe haven of gold against stocks and inflation in Iran. Modern Economy and Business, 14 (3), 71-95. (in Persian)
Kat, H. M., & Oomen, R. C. (2006). What every investor should know about commodities, Part II: Multivariate return analysis. Alternative Investment Research Centre Working Paper, (33).
Kaul, A. & Sapp, S. (2006). Y2K fears and safe haven trading of the US dollar. Journal of international money and finance, 25(5), 760-779.
Low, R. K. Y., Yao, Y. & Faff, R. (2016). Diamonds vs. precious metals: What shines brightest in your investment portfolio?. International Review of Financial Analysis, 43, 1-14.
Maller, R. A., Durand, R. B. & Jafarpour, H. (2010). Optimal portfolio choice using the maximum Sharpe ratio. The Journal of Risk, 12(4), 49.
Mjørud, F. & Haug, T. (2023). Enhancing the 60/40 Portfolio: The Value of Commodity Futures. Master's thesis, Handelshøyskolen BI.‏
Mohammadinejad Pashaki, M. B., Sadeghi Sharif, J. & Eghbalnia, M. (2023). Investigating and Analyzing the Spillover Effects among Stock, Currency, Gold, and Commodity Markets: VARMA-BEKKAGARCH Approach. Financial Research Journal, 25 (1). (in Persian)
Naeem, A.M., Hasan, M., Arif, M., Suleman, M.T. & Kang, S.H. (2022). Oil and gold as a hedge and safe-haven for metals and agricultural commodities with portfolio implications. Energy Economics 105, 105758.
Ozdemir. H. & Ozdemir. Z.A. (2021). A Survey of Hedge and Safe Havens Assets against G-7 Stock Markets before and during the COVID-19 Pandemic. The IZA Institute of Labor Economics No. 14888.
Pandey, V. (2023). Does Commodity Exposure Benefit Traditional Potfolios? Evidence From India. Journal of Investment Management and Financial Innovations, 20 (4).
Pirttiala, A. (2015). Investing for consumers: comparing returns of different investing instruments 2004-2014.
Seifoddini, J. & Rahnama Roodposhti, F. (2017). Gold as a safe haven for Tehran Stock Exchange: Mode change approach. Financial knowledge of Tehran securities analysis, 11 (40), 147-160. (in Persian)
Sensoy, A. (2013). Dynamic relationship between precious metals. Resources Policy, 38(4), 504-511.
Sesit, M.R. (2004). Commodities enter the investment mainstream. The Global Player 9 September. http://www.fullermoney.com/content/2004-09-09/ MichaelSesitCommodities THEGLOBALPLAYER.pdf.
Shakil, M.H., Mustapha, I.M., Tasnia, M. & Saiti, B. (2018). Gold a Hedge or a Safe Haven? An Application of ARDL. Journal of Economics, Finance and Administrative Science, 23(44), 60-76.
Vafai Ghaini, V., Afroozi, M. & Kimiyagari, A. M. (2017). Risk hedging and safe haven of assets with a case study of gold, dollar, oil stock market index in Iran. 15th International Industrial Engineering Conference, Yazd. (in Persian)
Wang, Y. M., Lin, C. F. & Li, Y. H. (2013). The Correlation and Hedging Effects between Commodity and Stock Markets. Journal of Applied Finance and Banking, 3(5), 269.
Financial Research Journal
Volume 26, Issue 4
2024
Pages 791-814

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics